Baking academy · 9 min
Yeast troubleshooting
Most flat breads are a temperature story, not a dead-yeast story.
A fair test
Stir a pinch of yeast into lukewarm water with a tiny pinch of sugar. In ten minutes it should smell bready and look foamy. Water that feels hot to a finger can kill it. Water from the fridge only makes you wait. Instant and active dry both work in these formulas. Active dry prefers that short wake-up. Instant can go straight into flour.
Salt and fat
Salt slows yeast, which is useful, but a pile of salt sitting on the yeast before flour is mixed can stun a small batch. Fat coats proteins and weakens gluten if it is dumped in before the dough has any strength. For enriched buns, mix to a shaggy dough, rest, then work the softened butter in.
Reading a ferment
Bulk fermentation is done when the dough has grown by about half, feels airy, and a floured finger leaves a dent that springs back slowly. Clock times in recipes assume a kitchen near 24°C. A cold stone room can take twice as long. A hot kitchen can finish early and then overproof, which shows up as a loaf that rises in the oven and then falls.
Troubleshooting
- No rise at all
Check the yeast date and the water temperature. Start a new preferment rather than adding more yeast to a salted, tired dough.
- Huge holes under a tight crust
The shaped loaf proofed too long or the oven was not hot enough to set the edge. Shorten the final proof and preheat longer.