Baking academy · 8 min
Creaming method and muffin method
The order of butter, sugar, and liquid decides whether a crumb is fine or coarse.
Creaming
Beat softened butter with sugar until the colour lightens and the grain of sugar mostly disappears. Eggs go in one at a time. Flour is folded at the end and stopped at the first sign that no dry streaks remain. This is the path for pound-style cakes, swirl buns' enriched dough cousins, and a fine orange olive-oil cake if you are using butter. Overbeating after flour makes tunnels.
Muffin method
Whisk dry ingredients in one bowl and wet ingredients in another. Pour wet into dry and stir briefly. Lumps are allowed. Banana bread, buttermilk biscuits' flaky cousin, and many quick loaves use this path. A smooth batter here is usually overmixed and bakes tough.
Cold fat versus soft fat
Biscuits and scones want cold butter left in pea-sized pieces so steam lifts layers. Cookies that should spread want softer butter. If a recipe in the academy says 'rub in', keep the butter cold. If it says 'cream', let the butter yield to a finger without melting.
Troubleshooting
- Butter seized when eggs went in
The butter was cold or the eggs were fridge-cold. Set the bowl over warm water for a minute and beat again. Do not melt the butter.
- Quick bread is rubbery
The batter was stirred too long. Mix only until the flour disappears and bake at once.